When people search for “the best high schools in Ohio,” they usually want more than a list. They want to know what each school is actually known for.

Some schools dominate in academics and college prep. Others shine in athletics, the arts, or flexible learning options that help students get back on track. What counts as “best” really depends on what kind of student you are,  and what you want from your high school experience.

We analyzed rankings from U.S. News & World Report, Niche, Google Reviews, and public data to find the top schools in Ohio and identify what makes each one stand out.

Best for Academics: Walnut Hills High School (Cincinnati)

Walnut Hills is often considered Ohio’s most academically rigorous public high school,  and for good reason. It ranks first in the state and among the top 50 nationwide, according to U.S. News & World Report.

Over 90 percent of students take AP or IB courses, and the graduation rate sits near 99 percent. Parents and students describe it as a place where driven learners thrive and teachers truly care.

“You have to be motivated to do all the work there, or else you won’t succeed — but the teachers will help you every step,” wrote one parent on Google.

 “The coursework is challenging, but I felt prepared for college,” added another reviewer on Niche.

Bottom line: Walnut Hills is ideal for students who want a challenge and are ready for a competitive, college-focused environment.

Best for STEM Excellence: Solon High School (Solon)

Solon High School consistently ranks among Ohio’s top three public schools. It’s particularly well-known for its STEM programs, with award-winning Science Olympiad and Robotics teams that compete nationally.

Students describe the teachers as approachable and the coursework as engaging, though they note the competitive culture can be intense.

“Our Science Olympiad team is one of the best in the country — and the teachers really care,” one student wrote on Niche.

“Super competitive, but everyone wants to see you win,” said another reviewer on Google.

Bottom line: Solon is perfect for high achievers who love science, math, and problem-solving — and who thrive in a results-driven atmosphere.

Best for Athletics and School Spirit: Olentangy Liberty High School (Powell)

For students who want the classic high school experience, complete with Friday night lights and strong academics, Olentangy Liberty High School delivers.

Liberty’s sports programs are among the strongest in the state, with championship-level football, cheerleading, and wrestling teams. Students and parents often mention the supportive staff and pride in the school community.

“The teachers care, and the athletics are phenomenal. It’s the full high school experience,” wrote one parent on Google.

Bottom line: Liberty offers a balanced mix of academics, athletics, and community pride that defines traditional high school success.

Best for Arts and Diversity: Shaker Heights High School (Cleveland)

Shaker Heights High School stands out for its inclusive culture and strong arts programs. With over 20 visual and performing arts options — from orchestra and choir to theater and media arts — students have room to explore their creativity.

Parents and alumni consistently praise the diversity and social awareness of the student body.

“There’s a club or program for every interest. The arts teachers are passionate and talented,” one student wrote on Niche.

Bottom line: Shaker Heights is the best choice for students who want a welcoming, diverse environment where creativity and expression are encouraged.

Best for Teacher Support and Mentorship: Rocky River High School (Cleveland Area)

Rocky River High School ranks near the top for teacher quality, earning the #3 spot in Ohio for “Best Public School Teachers,” according to Niche.

Students describe a warm, personal environment where teachers genuinely care about their success.

“Teachers prepare you for life beyond high school, not just tests,” said one parent in a Google Review.

Bottom line: Rocky River offers academic strength with an extra layer of personal attention — a great fit for students who value connection and mentorship.

Best for Close-Knit Community: Bexley High School (Columbus Area)

Bexley High School combines rigorous academics with a small, community-oriented feel. It’s ranked among Ohio’s top 10 schools and praised for strong teacher relationships and small class sizes.

“Bexley feels like a family. The teachers know you and want you to succeed,” wrote one reviewer on Niche.

Another parent noted, “The academics are very rigorous and almost all students demonstrate college readiness.”

Bottom line: Bexley is a great option for students who want a smaller school community where teachers are personally invested in their growth.

Best for Flexibility and Career Readiness: Career Prep High School (Statewide)

Career Prep High School is different from every other school on this list — because it’s designed for students who need a second chance or a more flexible schedule. We work with students who had life complications come up and prevent them from succeeding in traditional high school.

It’s tuition-free, and students can study online, in person, or both. Teachers provide one-on-one support, and students can earn job certifications in fields like healthcare, IT, and construction while finishing their diplomas. We help our students get their diploma as quickly as possible and move forward with their careers.

“Career Prep helped me graduate in eight months — and now I’m working in healthcare,” shared one graduate.

Bottom line: Career Prep is the best choice for students who need a personalized, career-focused path to earn a real high school diploma on their own schedule.

Finding the Right Fit

The best high school in Ohio isn’t the same for everyone. If you want an academic challenge, Walnut Hills or Solon may be right for you. For school spirit and sports, Olentangy Liberty is a top choice. For smaller classes and strong teacher connections, Bexley or Rocky River shine.

And if you need flexibility, personal support, and real-world training, Career Prep High School offers a free path to your diploma, and your future.